top of page
HoF for Web.jpg

Hall of Fame

New Carlisle boasts one of the richest Wiffle®Ball traditions in the country with the illustrious histories of The Wiffle®Ball Championship and Old Republic Wiffle®Ball League. Established in 2020, the New Carlisle Wiffle®Ball Hall of Fame honors the most impactful figures in the sport.

Hall of Fame Inductees

Shane Anderson

Maple City Magic

Class of 2020

Garrett Curless

New Carlisle Newts

Class of 2020

Matt Flagg

New Carlisle Newts

Class of 2020

Bob Keck

Contributor

Class of 2020

Drew Luther

Maple City Magic

Class of 2020

Seth Shail

The Muffs

Class of 2020

John Arndt

Looney Wifflers

Class of 2020

Wes Ellis

Maple City Magic

Class of 2020

Danny Hernandez

Cult West Warriors

Class of 2021

Kaylor Keck

New Carlisle Newts

Class of 2020

Jay Ryans

Cult West Warriors

Class of 2020

Matt Soos

Cult West Warriors

Class of 2022

Nick Arndt

Wills Township Federalists

Class of 2020

Jared Emmons

Pterodactyls

Class of 2020

Denis Jedrysek

Pterodactyls

Class of 2020

Koby Keck

New Carlisle Newts

Class of 2021

Matt Serge

Speedy's Chickenheads

Class of 2020

Scott Soos

Cult West Warriors

Class of 2020

Nominate a Wiffler

​Active and retired players, managers, and contributors to the game from either The Wiffle®Ball Championship and/or the Old Republic Wiffle®Ball League (ORWBL) are eligible to be nominated.

​

​

Voting shall be based upon the player's record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character, and contributions to the team(s) on which the player played. 

 

For nominees that fail to reach the threshold, they must be re-nominated to appear on subsequent ballots.

Nominations must be received by December 31 at 11:59pm ET to appear on the upcoming year's ballot. Nominees will be voted upon by the current members of the Hall of Fame and the Commissioner. To be inducted, a nominee must receive 75% of the vote on the ballots received. Announcements will be made annually in the spring.

Thanks for submitting!

© 2025 by New Carlisle Hometown Days.

bottom of page